Key Takeaways

  • The property sale fall-through rate across Edinburgh, the Lothians, Fife and the Borders currently stands at 11.74%, up 0.65 percentage points on 2025 and significantly above pre-pandemic levels of around 8%.
  • October saw a sharp increase, with 16.44% of property sales collapsing – the highest monthly figure of the year. November’s figures will help establish whether this is a lasting shift or a one-off spike.
  • There are significant regional differences, with the Borders recording the highest fall-through rate at 15.76%, followed by Edinburgh North West at 15.54%. Edinburgh South had the lowest rate at 9.15%.
  • Common reasons for sales falling through include delays while buyers sell their own properties, economic uncertainty affecting mortgage affordability, and buyers having second thoughts about offers above Home Report valuations.
  • Selling your existing property before searching for your next home can reduce chain-related risks and provide greater financial certainty. Bridging loans may also offer an option for keeping a purchase on track when a sale is delayed.

 

Concerned couple

Paul Hilton, CEO of leading Scottish property portal ESPC, shares insights into the rise of property sales falling through this year - and how October was the biggest shift.

When an offer is accepted on a property, most buyers and sellers assume that the sale will progress smoothly, and in most cases, property sales do proceed without a hitch – but over the last few years, we’ve seen a concerning rise in failed property sales. This can lead to extended property chains and in some cases, whole chains collapsing.

The current property sale fall-through rate across Edinburgh, the Lothians, Fife and the Borders is 11.74% of sales, which is 0.65 percentage points higher than 2025, and sits level with 2023 and 2024, where we saw the highest-ever rates of collapsing sales.

These rates are well above the pre-pandemic levels of circa 8%, and by this point, it may be fair to assume that what we’re seeing is in fact the ‘new normal’, and buyers and sellers should therefore expect some level of volatility when entering into a property purchase or sale - although, as I say, the vast majority do proceed as expected.

Property sales falling through: October sees a significant rise

Examining the figures, until September, this year’s rate was closely tracking what we saw in 2025, but October changed all of that. Last month, 16.44% of property sales across Edinburgh, the Lothians, Fife and the Borders collapsed, shifting the year’s trajectory. Of course, one month doesn’t make a trend, so November will show whether this is indeed a shift, or just a blip. Rates have fluctuated from over 12% in January to a low of 9.94% in March, hovering between 10% and 12% throughout the rest of the year, but no month has come close to October.

Areas vary widely, so local context is important. Edinburgh North West had a property sale fall-through rate of 15.54%, while the Borders had the highest at 15.76%. Edinburgh East and Edinburgh South saw the lowest levels, at 9.74% and 9.15% respectively.

Why are property sales falling through?

So why are so many sales falling through? After speaking with our solicitor estate member firms, it seems that many are down to sellers tiring of waiting for their buyers’ own property to sell, after accepting an initial offer ‘subject to sale’. Some buyers may be holding out for a high offer that’s taking too long to come (especially in a market where there are currently more properties available than buyers), and sellers simply need to get on or risk losing their own onward purchase. It’s certainly a case for selling your property before buying your next home; not only does this speed up the process for everyone, but there’s less risk involved, and with a safe offer accepted, you know exactly how much money you have for your next purchase.

Of course, the other likely reason is the economic climate. Instability may mean threats of redundancies leading to cold feet, or buyers could be finding that when it comes to progressing with their mortgage application, they no longer meet the criteria they assumed they would and cannot secure the amount they need to borrow.

Another factor which may be at play is buyers offering above the Home Report valuation. We may be seeing higher instances of buyers securing a purchase with a higher offer and then getting cold feet, or feeling like they may have gotten carried away, after looking at the wider market and current selling prices for similar properties. Of course, any offer made above the Home Report valuation must be funded by the buyer's own savings and cannot be covered in the mortgage amount. The current average amount paid is 101.9%, but again this varies - buyers pay 103.1% on average in Edinburgh East, for example.

How can buyers and sellers prevent a property sale falling through?

So, what can be done? Alongside very careful consideration around affordability, bridging loans may be an option to prevent a sale falling through, or potentially a whole chain collapsing. Alistair Ewing of The Lending Channel explains that while bridging loan fees are higher than traditional mortgage rates (circa 6.5% at the lower end), rates are possibly not as onerous as many may believe and as the loan can be arranged quickly and paid off when the sale is completed, it could be a reassuring way to keep things afloat.

Sales collapsing will already cost both the buyer and seller in legal fees and remarketing a property, but also in emotional stress and uncertainty, so it may be worth considering all options. Bridging can also effectively make you a chain-free buyer, which could make your own offers more attractive.

It remains to be seen how the rest of 2026 will play out, but with a base rate rise and a continuing difficult financial environment for most, it’s certainly too soon to say whether we can expect to see this trend die down in the months to come or whether this truly is the ‘new normal’. The message remains clear however, that by securing your own sale first, you stand a better chance of a smoother onward experience, and a lower chance of your property chain collapsing later down the line.

Please note that the information and data included in this article were correct as of November 2026 and may have changed since the time of writing.